Home > About Addictions > Addiction and the Law

Addiction and the Law

By: David Vetter - Updated: 4 Mar 2013 | comments*Discuss
 
Addiction Addicts Uk Britain Law

When it comes to addiction, our legal system faces a quandary. Drug addiction can be characterised as a state of dependence on a substance that can result in behavioural change. The difficulty is that the law may only punish us for the actions for which we have control. If an addiction causes an addict to carry out a crime, yet he is not fully responsible for his actions, what is the law to do?

One side of the argument says that addiction is not an illness, and should not be treated as such. A crime, they say, is a crime. But opponents of this view say that addiction is indeed an illness, and that jailing addicts does nothing to solve the problem.

Addiction and British Law

The main body of legislation on drug addiction can be found in the Misuse of Drugs Act 1971. Since this law came into force, our understanding of drugs and addiction has gone through huge changes, and the law has seen a series of amendments. The most sweeping changes were brought about in 2005 with the new Drugs Act. However, the basic premise, that all illegal drugs are dangerous and those who take them are criminals, remains the same. Critics argue that if we are to ever tackle the problem effectively, a more objective approach is needed.

The 1971 Act brought the current drug classifications of A, B and C into usage, with “A” being used for what we often refer to as “hard drugs”. These classifications have provoked enormous controversy: Some class A drugs, such as ecstasy, cause no physical dependency, and are relatively harmless when compared with heroin or crystal meth. This has led the Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs, an independent panel of experts, to recommend the “declassification” of ecstasy. The government, however, has refused, considering the political effects of such a declassification too damaging.

In its current form, the law now states that anyone possessing a class A drug can now be jailed for up to seven years, or fined, or both. However, “possession with intent to supply” Class A drugs can result in life imprisonment. This is important, because anyone found in possession of a quantity of drugs over a prescribed amount can automatically be assumed to have intent to supply.

However, the 2005 Act does introduce broader grounds for the treatment of addicts. Courts can now recommend offenders for treatment and community service instead of prison – though it is still down to the court's decision.

The law also draws the connection between addiction and other crimes, and people arrested for burglary or shoplifting can now be tested for addiction. The intention is that addicts ought to be treated differently to other criminals, and their drug dependency taken into account. However, theft and other crimes are often treated without regard for any connection to addiction: Addicts with little control over their compulsion can still very easily find themselves behind bars. However, according to Drugscope, a leading UK independent drugs information centre, few addicts actually take up crime as a direct result of addiction.

Those placed on Anti-Social Behaviour Orders (ASBOs) can also be tested for drug use. It is hoped that the police will use these powers in order to provide the relevant treatment to offenders.

A New Approach

According to UK law, it still seems that those addicted to drugs are invariably regarded as criminals. Whilst there have been marginal changes to the way the law operates, and while testing and treatment for addiction is becoming more commonplace, there is still a tendency to cast drug addicts as villains, rather than victims.

But whilst addicts might be responsible for contracting their illness, must they also be held accountable for the symptoms?

The crimes of addicts, combined with the cost of locking them up, amounts to a total cost of billions of pounds every year. The effectiveness of treatment, as opposed to punishment, has demonstrated that dealing with the illness itself, rather than its consequences, is not only more beneficial for the individuals concerned, but also dramatically less costly for the taxpayer and society. But it may yet be some time before politicians develop the courage to move away from the demonisation of addicts, and start promoting answers.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Topics
Latest Comments
  • Stephy
    Re: Physical Effects of Alcohol
    I want to help my best friend with his dependency on alcohol - he is depressed - has started going to AA but I fear he isn’t making…
    4 April 2018
  • Mykon
    Re: Effects of Withdrawal from an Addiction
    It Was A Big Fight. Reading True This Write Up Helped Alot. It Was Revealing.. I Need Help With The Issue Of…
    29 March 2018
  • BeatingAddictions
    Re: How to Assess The Level of an Addiction
    Bean125 - Your Question:Myself and my sister are both in education, she lives with my mum going to college and I…
    19 March 2018
  • Bean125
    Re: How to Assess The Level of an Addiction
    Myself and my sister are both in education, she lives with my mum going to college and I moved away to study at a…
    17 March 2018
  • BeatingAddictions
    Re: Addiction and Genes
    damo210 - Your Question:Hi, I have a very addictive personality. I have previously had a gambling problem, managed to stop for a while but…
    12 March 2018
  • damo210
    Re: Addiction and Genes
    Hi, I have a very addictive personality. I have previously had a gambling problem, managed to stop for a while but there is always something…
    11 March 2018
  • BeatingAddictions
    Re: Support Groups
    Darren18 - Your Question:Hi I don't really know what to write or how to go about it. But yesterday I come home from work and my partner and kids were g
    1 March 2018
  • Darren18
    Re: Support Groups
    Hi I don't really know what to write or how to go about it. But yesterday I come home from work and my partner and kids were gone. All there…
    28 February 2018
  • MandR
    Re: How to Assess The Level of an Addiction
    @Bennett - I hope you are seeking help for it. Admitting you have a problem and seeking help to deal with it is the…
    27 February 2018
  • Bennett
    Re: How to Assess The Level of an Addiction
    I have a binge drinking & drugs problem
    26 February 2018
Further Reading...
Our Most Popular...
Add to my Yahoo!
Add to Google
Stumble this
Add to Twitter
Add To Facebook
RSS feed
You should seek independent professional advice before acting upon any information on the BeatingAddictions website. Please read our Disclaimer.